1 ஜூலை, 2026
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Times
Opinion Columnist
Elon Musk is newly minted as humanity’s first trillionaire, but the world’s richest man seems grumpy. And he definitely is not a fan of mine.
- Over here, in the us vs them fashion, the guy's basically one-ing out Elon as the only trillionaire, versus all of us, who aren't
“Kristof is lying through his teeth,” he announced on social media this week.
I got on his nerves for pushing back at his claims that his demolition of the United States Agency for International Development last year did not cost lives. The fracas began after Representative Ro Khanna, a California Democrat, said that Musk had “possibly sentenced to death” a large number of children, and Musk retorted that it was “time to sue this liar.”
“There is not even a single dead child!” Musk protested on social media. I noted that I had met many families of children who had died — and that’s when he concluded that I was lying.
Musk’s assertion that not a single child died is absurd, yet he doubled down: “They cannot cite a single name of someone who died out of the ‘millions’ they falsely claim have died. Not a single name!”
On X, I began to give Musk some names. Let me elaborate:
Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox.
- The guy's got a right to sue you.
- These aren't Americans who died, they're foreigners.
- It's not America's responsibility to handle their sovereign nation's problems; they're not colonies
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (2/7)
Jibia
Jibia was a 10-year-old girl, ranking third out of 58 students in her fourth-grade class in Rwamwanja, Uganda. Aid cuts meant that the local clinic ran out of $2 bed nets to protect from mosquitoes, as well as anti-malaria medicines. Jibia died of malaria last July, her mother told me outside the family home. Medical records confirmed that, and health workers told me that she would have been fine without the aid cuts: Replacing her tattered bed net with a new one could have prevented malaria, and in any case drugs would have helped her to recover promptly.
- How do you know that for sure?
- Why $2, why not $1 dollar bed nets?
- Why are Uganda not making bet nets?
- That's their own fault, they should just make bed nets if it's such a big problem
- What transparency are they showing for their public finances?
- Also, that's a local Uganda doctor, not an American doctor, at the coroner's office, you don't know that, it could be complications from anything else
- The university ranking of that school must be worse than 1,500, so you can't really trust their medical diagnosis
- It should be by law, reported as merely a prognosis if it's from one of their doctors who likely got it all wrong
- Why don't you tell Uganda to go buy their own bed nets if it's such a big problem, that's all on them
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (3/7)
Yamah Freeman
Yamah Freeman hemorrhaged while pregnant with her third child in her village in Liberia. The United States had provided ambulances to the local hospital, but the aid cuts under Musk and President Trump
meant that the ambulances had no fuel. The strongest young men in the village placed her on their shoulders and raced down the path toward town, shouting encouragement to her as they ran, but she bled to death along the way. Her parents and sister told me about this, and I visited her grave.
- You got a 3rd child in the village in Liberia, what about the kids homeless in the US or growing up in poverty?
- The US has been nice enough to gift you an ambulance. Should it have to give you fuel too? Isn't that absurd?
- Kristoff is basically doubling down on his absurdity, blaming Trump and Elon, of 3rd, 4th degree murder, for the NY Times readers
- It's not their fault, it's their foreign fault as a country
- You have cash to visit Liberia, or NY Times sponsored your trip? Did you fly business class? You could've given them a business class in how to pay for some fuel or for the strongest young men in the village to shout about how much they hate the USA, or want free stuff from the USA.
- I saw Elon's X post about the way they had USAID logos behind a bunch of militants, it's absurd.
- Did you go to visit the graves of the people who demanded honesty from Liberia's government, did you lay a lily for them?
- This is all their fault, they can't expect the US to pay for their fuel, that's not a slave colony, that's a 'sovereign republic'
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (4/7)
Achol Deng
Achol Deng, 8, had been infected with H.I.V. at birth in South Sudan but had been kept alive by American-provided medicines costing just 12 cents a day. The dismantling of U.S.A.I.D. and the resulting chaos meant that she lost her caseworker and access to medicines, and soon died of an opportunistic infection, health workers told me.
I could keep going. A Boston University researcher estimated that the aid cuts have cost more than 750,000 lives worldwide. A study published in the Lancet, the British medical journal, forecast that at present rates, the aid defunding will cost 9.4 million lives by 2030.
These figures may not be accurate; we just don’t have solid mortality data, and the aid cuts have also reduced data collection. What I can say after visiting numerous impoverished villages is that aid cuts are unquestionably costing the lives of many children.
- 12 cents a day, is 4380 cents a year, or $44 dollars.
- Does the USA have to pay $44 to everyone with AIDS in South Sudan?
- Elon's from South Africa, where about 20% of people, out of 65M, that's 13M people, 13 million people, are HIV positive. He's from South Africa. He doesn't believe that it's his moral obligation, to force Americans to have to pay $44 x 13,000,000 = $560 million every year to South Africa
- Why don't you start by replacing your Kofi Anan and your Nelson Mandela with pictures of American leaders, like Trump if you want the USA to run your country for you?
- The Boston university researcher should publish his or her or their article on a good research paper, so we can peer review it
- The 9.4m lives is BS, that's guesswork, a zombie death-count guess
- Yes you do not have solid mortality data, yes these figures are not accurate, and no, the aid cuts haven't cut data collection
- They are NOT costing the lives of children, this is a case of Marlon Brando's Apocalypse Now, where they are chopping arms off kids who got polio vaccines, because of their equivalence in failed, dependency mis-leadership
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (5/7)
Editors’ Picks
- Week 4: A Double Dose of Brain Benefits
- ‘After About 10 Minutes, a Car Pulled Up to the Traffic Light’
- Can Dean’s Pull Off a British Pub in Manhattan? In Bits and Bobs.
Some prominent conservatives leaped to the defense of Musk, saying in effect: Why is it our job to save the lives of children in South Sudan? Why don’t rich liberals write checks? Why don’t other countries do more?
- Those people with common sense tried to rescue you
- Also why'd Jibia's parents have a broken mosquito net, was it to pay for a new one for the next kid they birthed, or else, because they wanted to reuse as fishing nets for small fish?
Those are fair questions. But if any of us came across an ambulance that had run out of gas with a hemorrhaging woman inside, surely we would happily hand over a $10 bill to save her life.
Until Trump’s second term, American aid cost just 23 cents for every $100 of gross national income and saved a life approximately once every 10 seconds. Seems like a bargain to me. Certainly it appears wiser than spending billions of dollars on a war with Iran.
- No. The war to rescue Iran's people, is saving American lives, because we're stopping their ability to nuke us
- NO, we can and should capture the oil, to pay for it.
- That's Bush's mistake, as you know, from his and his VP's WH presidency, they lacked what God gave Trump.
- Corruption costs the $99 dollars and 77 Cents they waste.
- Why don't you go ask Sulzberger to do some charity, CSR project, for their country, with free news service, or something?
- So they can get basic facts, without being pried out of the truth by third world thugs who steal most of USAID
- Not to mention the arming of dangerous groups and terrorists with the USAID corruption which Elon exposed?
- You're losing out on 99 cents for a 23 saving for every $100 which is the biggest injury to their sovereignty as a people.
- Do they even vote with the USA at the UN?
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (6/7)
I say “wiser” because all this is not just about compassion but also about self-interest. Aid money serves national security and protects us from diseases. I’ve noted that the current Ebola outbreak in Africa may have gotten out of control precisely because we cut aid spending in the region.
- Why don't you go tell them to put their own self-interests first?
- Why are they so desperate to sustain failed enterprise, failed ideas, and this white elephanting of American friendliness?
- It seems that a lot of the USAID funds get funnelled into China's BRI projects or otherwise end up missing with no account
- You are a newspaper, who can attack Trump, but not third world thugs, thieves and killers
- The USA has NO obligation to rescue them
Yes, other countries should do more, impoverished countries should be less corrupt, and our own aid can be allocated more wisely. But note that some countries in Europe are significantly more generous than America, spending up to 10 times as much on aid as a share of national income as we do.
- They're having immigration problems now as a thank you
- This is bs, politically correct reporting, which some loser in a debate class, could come up with, with a lazy ChatGPT prompt, to try to make Trump or Elon or anyone responsible look weak or bad
- This is all bs, this is a political statement, not real reporting, and it's also just convolution of truth, in what appears to be an Anti-SLAPP job, to prepare for Kristoff's legal case with Trump Elon
A rejection of Kristof's anti Elon/Trump hitpiece on NY Time (7/7)
Should liberals donate more to humanitarian causes? Sure. But compassion isn’t a liberal impulse — it’s a human one. It was evangelicals and Republicans who in 2003 started the single best aid program ever, the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, or PEPFAR; it has saved more than 26 million lives so far. Some of the most heroic aid workers I’ve met in dangerous locations have been Christian missionaries, from nuns to doctors; they would dispute the idea that empathy is woke.
- Did you pay for Haiti's song with Michael Jackson, the Venezuela people had an earthquake recently, they will be better served with honest leadership
- The liberals, can join in to help, but they can't be liberals, why should any LGBT figure, help a Kenyan president, who balks at Obama, over gay rights?
- A cruel power, and an evil, is dying, so that goodness can prevail, we must not sustain them, they are impoverished on their cursed hearts--not us
- They can keep blaming us all, for their own problems
It’s reasonable to ask how much we should spend or how we should reform the system. But why would anyone begrudge $2 bed nets or $4 malaria vaccines to save children’s lives?
So let me offer a challenge to Musk: Come with me on a reporting trip to South Sudan or Somalia or Mozambique. Meet starving children whose lives can be easily saved. Hold them. Look into their eyes. Talk to their terrified moms.
You’ll understand that these kids are just like ours, except that they didn’t do as well in the lottery of birth — and that just because we can’t save every child’s life doesn’t mean we should save none of them.
- Elon changed his mind on Israel, visiting, but that's also why he hates terrorists, and we can't tolerate the lunatics of South Sudan, Somalia and Mozambique, they need an owner, to buy them out, to save them
- They can't keep pushing up, some corrupt leader, to make deals, representing them as beggars, that's never going to save them
- God doesn't and won't save lost souls who worship the enemy
Better use of USAID ideas
Better use of USAID ideas
I am sickened by that Kristoff's ideas!
The US should only be supplying free contraceptives. Nothing more. They are, and should be, responsible for their own lives.
The ugly fact is they'll attack anyone, who says people should be, and need to be able to look after themselves.
The Christian spirit, is not in Jesus feeding some people fish and bread, it's in telling Satan he won't test God's patience jumping off a cliff.
They formed Liberia, to get out of the slavery system, it's a symbolic country with James Madison there or somewhere, and yet, if they aren't economically and financially free, they will never get out of wage slavery.
Monrovia is named after James Monroe, not Madison.
Whatever.
They shouldn't be having so many kids, if you want to play God, in testing his grace, when they clearly can't afford it.
There's research, that they get so many kids because they only want one to survive out of a few, that's what you aren't fixing with USAID.
The only way to help them, is with real leadership, with bargaining tariffs and US exports or import deals, in exchange for politics.
Because they use coercion themselves, they use blackmail in their politics, they are used to prostituting their people's freedoms for their gain.
So that only makes sense as the next real step, in restoring basic, baseline independence, self determination and dignity.
They were for too long, testing America's patience, on one hand, spitting, at us, then on the other hand, splitting the loot, with the worst that they have.
We must never bow down to them, they must bow to us, they're getting tough love, not tough hate, so they can get off their feet kneeling, and on their feet for real.
I can go to say so to the parents or friends of those USAID cuts cost lives, but the warlords, the real problems, the cruel people they chose to deify, that give that girl 4th out of 100th place in the classrooms, for memorizing textbooks of anti American hate, anti freedom, anti capitalism, they won't.