-
Rome controlled Jerusalem longer than any other state, ruling for approximately 676 years. The Kingdom of Judah ranks second with 414 years, followed by the Ottoman Empire with 401 years; presenter Matt Baker treats the Roman and Byzantine empires as one continuous state.
-
The Israelites probably emerged from existing Canaanite populations rather than arriving as an entirely separate people. Following the Bronze Age Collapse around 1200 BCE, Canaanite hill-country communities developed a distinct identity; the biblical account places David's conquest of Jerusalem around 1000 BCE, although the early chronology remains uncertain.
-
Jerusalem remained a major Jewish religious center under several foreign empires. Persian rulers permitted Jews to return and rebuild their temple after Babylon's conquest in 586 BCE, while Greek rulers generally preserved Jewish religious practice until Seleucid interference helped provoke the Maccabean Revolt.
-
Jerusalem's two Jewish temples were destroyed by different empires, fundamentally changing the city's religious history. Nebuchadnezzar's Babylonians destroyed the First Temple in 586 BCE, while Roman forces destroyed the Second Temple in 70 CE; no Jewish temple has been rebuilt there since.
-
The Islamic conquest of 636 CE began centuries of predominantly Muslim rule while preserving Jewish and Christian religious communities. The Dome of the Rock, built in 691, occupies the sacred area associated with the Jewish temples and is a shrine distinct from the nearby Al-Aqsa Mosque.
-
The Crusaders violently ended nearly five centuries of Muslim dominance when they captured Jerusalem in 1099. They massacred much of the Muslim and Jewish population and established a Christian kingdom, but Saladin recaptured the city in 1187; Christians briefly regained it through a treaty between 1229 and 1244.
-
Islam leads Baker's historical religious tally with approximately 1,283 years, followed by Judaism with 1,197 and Christianity with 410. These totals overlap because he credits both Judaism and Islam from 1850 onward, when Jerusalem's growing Jewish population had become roughly equal to its Muslim population.
-
Israel has exercised effective control over Jerusalem since 1967, but sovereignty remains disputed by Palestinians. After British rule ended in 1948, Israel and Jordan divided the city for 19 years; Baker argues that its varied history defeats exclusive religious claims and favors shared control within a two-state solution.
“based on history no one culture or religion can claim to have an exclusive right to the city” — Matt Baker