-
No single DNA test was best for everyone because the five services examined served different purposes. Matt Baker found CircleDNA strongest for health information, FamilyTreeDNA for advanced genetic genealogy, 23andMe for combining health and ancestry, AncestryDNA for North American family research, and MyHeritage for European and Jewish genealogy.
-
CircleDNA offered the most extensive health testing but was also the most expensive. Its $629 premium package examined risks associated with 36 hereditary cancers and 79 other conditions, carrier status for 163 inherited conditions, and potential responses to 103 FDA-approved medications; the basic package cost $189.
-
Baker's own medical history demonstrated why DNA risk predictions cannot be treated as diagnoses. CircleDNA identified elevated susceptibility to type 2 diabetes but did not flag ulcerative colitis, which he had developed in his twenties, illustrating the influence of environmental and other factors beyond genetics.
“genetics is not destiny”
-
Autosomal, mitochondrial, and Y-chromosome tests investigate different parts of a family tree. Autosomal DNA reflects ancestry from both parents, mitochondrial DNA follows the direct maternal line, and Y-DNA traces the direct paternal line; the latter two can reveal lineages extending tens of thousands of years into the past.
-
FamilyTreeDNA provided the deepest specialist lineage reports, but obtaining all three test types cost $360. Its $80 autosomal test excluded mitochondrial testing ($160 extra) and Y-DNA testing ($120 extra), making the full package most appropriate for experienced genealogists interested in detailed mutations and haplogroups.
-
AncestryDNA produced Baker's most convincing ethnicity results and offered the strongest North American relative-matching database in his comparison. Its $100 test correctly identified his German, English, and Irish origins and ancestral connections to Nova Scotia, while historical-record access required an additional subscription of approximately $25 monthly.
-
MyHeritage offered a cheaper alternative to AncestryDNA, with particular advantages for European and Jewish genealogy. Its $80 cheek-swab test identified Baker's Nova Scotia connections, provided relative matching and family-tree tools, and offered access to European records through a separate paid membership.
-
23andMe combined ancestry and health testing while including haplogroup information without separate specialist purchases. Genealogy testing cost $100, the combined package cost $200, and customers received ethnicity estimates, relative matches, genetic health reports, and additional research-based updates over time.
-
DNA relative matching uncovered a first cousin Baker had never known existed. They connected online and discovered that they shared a health problem, illustrating both the personal value of genetic genealogy and its potential to reveal unexpected biological relationships.